Eight very different couples deal with their love lives in various loosely interrelated tales all set during a frantic month before Christmas in London.
Richard Curtis's overlapping-storylines Christmas romcom split critics down the middle on release — too many plots, too little depth per story, yet an undeniably charming ensemble — and has only grown more divisive since, becoming a holiday ritual for millions while other critics and publications have sharpened their knives into full-on takedowns. The gap between its cult popularity and its critical reputation is itself the defining fact about the film.
“a belly-flop into the sea of romantic comedy ... The movie's only flaw is also a virtue: ... It feels a little like a gourmet meal that turns into a hot-dog eating contest.”
Roger Ebert·Chicago Sun-Times
“a romantic comedy swollen to the length of an Oscar-trawling epic”
A. O. Scott·The New York Times
“There are laughs laced with feeling here, but the deft screenwriter Richard Curtis dilutes the impact by tossing in more and more stories.”
Peter Travers·Rolling Stone
“love British style, handicapped slightly by corny circumstance and populated by colorful neurotics”
Michael Atkinson·The Village Voice
Comedy, Drama, Romance
Eight very different couples deal with their love lives in various loosely interrelated tales all set during a frantic month before Christmas in London.
Richard Curtis's overlapping-storylines Christmas romcom split critics down the middle on release — too many plots, too little depth per story, yet an undeniably charming ensemble — and has only grown more divisive since, becoming a holiday ritual for millions while other critics and publications have sharpened their knives into full-on takedowns. The gap between its cult popularity and its critical reputation is itself the defining fact about the film.
“a belly-flop into the sea of romantic comedy ... The movie's only flaw is also a virtue: ... It feels a little like a gourmet meal that turns into a hot-dog eating contest.”
Roger Ebert·Chicago Sun-Times
“a romantic comedy swollen to the length of an Oscar-trawling epic”
A. O. Scott·The New York Times
“There are laughs laced with feeling here, but the deft screenwriter Richard Curtis dilutes the impact by tossing in more and more stories.”
Peter Travers·Rolling Stone
“love British style, handicapped slightly by corny circumstance and populated by colorful neurotics”
Michael Atkinson·The Village Voice
Comedy, Drama, Romance