Rizwan Khan, a Muslim from the Borivali section of Mumbai, has Asperger's syndrome. He marries a Hindu single mother, Mandira, in San Francisco. After 9/11, Rizwan is detained by authorities at LAX who treat him as a terrorist because of his condition and his race.
Shah Rukh Khan's portrayal of a man with Asperger's syndrome drew near-universal admiration from Indian critics, and the film's first half was widely regarded as Karan Johar working with unusual restraint and maturity. The second half — particularly a flood-rescue sequence and what many called a forced, over-heroic climax — is where the film lost a significant number of reviewers, and the gap between warm domestic reception and cooler international critical opinion is real and worth knowing about.
“It works only in the first half. Post interval there's too much drama, in particular the flood scene. They were trying to make a hero of an ordinary man. That spoilt the effect of the first half.”
Maithili Rao·Man's World
“an expensive and empty vessel”
Ajit Duara·Open
“Completely getting under the skin of the character, Shah Rukh has picked up every single nuance of an Asperger's syndrome patient without making it appear labored.”
The Hindu
Drama, Romance
Rizwan Khan, a Muslim from the Borivali section of Mumbai, has Asperger's syndrome. He marries a Hindu single mother, Mandira, in San Francisco. After 9/11, Rizwan is detained by authorities at LAX who treat him as a terrorist because of his condition and his race.
Shah Rukh Khan's portrayal of a man with Asperger's syndrome drew near-universal admiration from Indian critics, and the film's first half was widely regarded as Karan Johar working with unusual restraint and maturity. The second half — particularly a flood-rescue sequence and what many called a forced, over-heroic climax — is where the film lost a significant number of reviewers, and the gap between warm domestic reception and cooler international critical opinion is real and worth knowing about.
“It works only in the first half. Post interval there's too much drama, in particular the flood scene. They were trying to make a hero of an ordinary man. That spoilt the effect of the first half.”
Maithili Rao·Man's World
“an expensive and empty vessel”
Ajit Duara·Open
“Completely getting under the skin of the character, Shah Rukh has picked up every single nuance of an Asperger's syndrome patient without making it appear labored.”
The Hindu
Drama, Romance