In postwar Germany, an American psychiatrist must determine whether Nazi prisoners are fit to go on trial for war crimes, and finds himself in a complex battle of intellect and ethics with Hermann Göring, Hitler's right-hand man.
Broadly watchable but cautious, the film earns its most consistent praise for Russell Crowe's work while dividing critics over whether its old-fashioned, earnest approach is a feature or a flaw. Rami Malek's performance drew particular fire, and many felt the direction leans too hard on awards-drama conventions to fully reckon with its weighty subject.
“It's a solid film of [a] kind that used to be more common: an earnest, unpretentious Oscar Movie that wants to be seen by everyone, and consequently doesn't try to be too complex or arty. It wants to educate and inspire as well as entertain, and isn't shy about that ambition.”
Matt Zoller Seitz·RogerEbert.com
“Nuremberg is constructed like an old-fashioned awards-bait period piece, complete with trailer-ready lines of dialogue that put a neat-and-tidy button on scenes. There's a mechanical quality to Vanderbilt's plotting that negates the unexpected and enlightening.”
Nick Schrager·The Daily Beast
“All of these actors do their best, but the figure of Kelley himself is a ridiculous cartoon.”
Peter Bradshaw·The Guardian
“well-intentioned and elucidating despite some missteps.”
Los Angeles Times
Biography, Drama, History
In postwar Germany, an American psychiatrist must determine whether Nazi prisoners are fit to go on trial for war crimes, and finds himself in a complex battle of intellect and ethics with Hermann Göring, Hitler's right-hand man.
Broadly watchable but cautious, the film earns its most consistent praise for Russell Crowe's work while dividing critics over whether its old-fashioned, earnest approach is a feature or a flaw. Rami Malek's performance drew particular fire, and many felt the direction leans too hard on awards-drama conventions to fully reckon with its weighty subject.
“It's a solid film of [a] kind that used to be more common: an earnest, unpretentious Oscar Movie that wants to be seen by everyone, and consequently doesn't try to be too complex or arty. It wants to educate and inspire as well as entertain, and isn't shy about that ambition.”
Matt Zoller Seitz·RogerEbert.com
“Nuremberg is constructed like an old-fashioned awards-bait period piece, complete with trailer-ready lines of dialogue that put a neat-and-tidy button on scenes. There's a mechanical quality to Vanderbilt's plotting that negates the unexpected and enlightening.”
Nick Schrager·The Daily Beast
“All of these actors do their best, but the figure of Kelley himself is a ridiculous cartoon.”
Peter Bradshaw·The Guardian
“well-intentioned and elucidating despite some missteps.”
Los Angeles Times
Biography, Drama, History