The hot-headed young D'Artagnan along with three former legendary but now down on their luck Musketeers must unite and defeat a beautiful double agent and her villainous employer from seizing the French throne and engulfing Europe in war.
Critics largely dismissed this swashbuckling adaptation as a hollow spectacle — flashy airship battles and Hong Kong-style stunt work couldn't compensate for a story that felt neither fun enough to work as comedy nor gripping enough to work as adventure. The one real fault line was whether the film's cheerful disregard for Dumas was a feature or a bug: most found it pointless, while a minority welcomed it as breezy disposable entertainment.
“Only Matthew Macfadyen's Athos exhibits the semblance of a personality ... Without drama or reverence for its source and lacking any genuine interest in history or literature, the film offers small pleasures with its visual kicks, found principally in protracted scenes of battling airships and generic stunt work adapted from Hong Kong action movies”
Stephen Holden·The New York Times
“Not original enough to be funny, nor serious enough to be gripping, this film seemed to go on forever, and then ended with the threat of a sequel”
Robbie Collin·The Daily Telegraph
“It's as though the screenplay was brainstormed by Alexandre Dumas and Jules Verne ... pure multiplex mulch, as disposable as it is entertaining”
Jim Schembri·The Sydney Morning Herald
Adventure, Action, Thriller
The hot-headed young D'Artagnan along with three former legendary but now down on their luck Musketeers must unite and defeat a beautiful double agent and her villainous employer from seizing the French throne and engulfing Europe in war.
Critics largely dismissed this swashbuckling adaptation as a hollow spectacle — flashy airship battles and Hong Kong-style stunt work couldn't compensate for a story that felt neither fun enough to work as comedy nor gripping enough to work as adventure. The one real fault line was whether the film's cheerful disregard for Dumas was a feature or a bug: most found it pointless, while a minority welcomed it as breezy disposable entertainment.
“Only Matthew Macfadyen's Athos exhibits the semblance of a personality ... Without drama or reverence for its source and lacking any genuine interest in history or literature, the film offers small pleasures with its visual kicks, found principally in protracted scenes of battling airships and generic stunt work adapted from Hong Kong action movies”
Stephen Holden·The New York Times
“Not original enough to be funny, nor serious enough to be gripping, this film seemed to go on forever, and then ended with the threat of a sequel”
Robbie Collin·The Daily Telegraph
“It's as though the screenplay was brainstormed by Alexandre Dumas and Jules Verne ... pure multiplex mulch, as disposable as it is entertaining”
Jim Schembri·The Sydney Morning Herald
Adventure, Action, Thriller
Stream