When Carrie's big step forward in her relationship goes awry, best friends Charlotte, Miranda and Samantha are there to help her pick up the pieces.
Critics split sharply on whether the film honored its source material or simply stretched a TV episode past its natural limits — fans of the show found enough warmth and wit to satisfy, while detractors argued the characters had calcified into fashion props rather than people. The gendered nature of the criticism itself became a subplot, with at least one writer openly questioning whether male reviewers came in hostile.
“a vulgar, shrill, deeply shallow—and, at 2 hours and 22 turgid minutes, overlong—addendum to a show”
Manohla Dargis·The New York Times
“the ladies have become frozen, Spice Girls-style types–angsty, neurotic, predatory, princess–rather than individuals who might evolve or surprise us”
Sukhdev Sandhu·The Daily Telegraph
“superannuated fantasy posing as a slice of modern life”
Anthony Lane·The New Yorker
“the film tackles weighty issues with grace but is still very funny”
Carina Chocano·Los Angeles Times
“The movie might not be Citizen Kane—which, for the record, is a dude flick—but it's incredibly sweet and touching.”
Ramin Setoodeh·Newsweek
Comedy, Drama, Romance
When Carrie's big step forward in her relationship goes awry, best friends Charlotte, Miranda and Samantha are there to help her pick up the pieces.
Critics split sharply on whether the film honored its source material or simply stretched a TV episode past its natural limits — fans of the show found enough warmth and wit to satisfy, while detractors argued the characters had calcified into fashion props rather than people. The gendered nature of the criticism itself became a subplot, with at least one writer openly questioning whether male reviewers came in hostile.
“a vulgar, shrill, deeply shallow—and, at 2 hours and 22 turgid minutes, overlong—addendum to a show”
Manohla Dargis·The New York Times
“the ladies have become frozen, Spice Girls-style types–angsty, neurotic, predatory, princess–rather than individuals who might evolve or surprise us”
Sukhdev Sandhu·The Daily Telegraph
“superannuated fantasy posing as a slice of modern life”
Anthony Lane·The New Yorker
“the film tackles weighty issues with grace but is still very funny”
Carina Chocano·Los Angeles Times
“The movie might not be Citizen Kane—which, for the record, is a dude flick—but it's incredibly sweet and touching.”
Ramin Setoodeh·Newsweek
Comedy, Drama, Romance