On the brink of turning 30, a promising theater composer navigates love, friendship and the pressure to create something great before time runs out.
Lin-Manuel Miranda's directing debut earned wide praise for centering Jonathan Larson's story with humility and specificity, with Andrew Garfield's musical performance and Robin de Jesús's breakout turn drawing particular attention. The main fault line in criticism runs through the documentary-style framing device, which even admirers felt reduced Larson to his most famous work, and through the film's treatment of the AIDS crisis — expansive compared to its source material, but still viewed through the lens of a straight man who survived it, a perspective critics found incomplete.
“a totem for the thrills and trials of making art, with all the sacrifices and empathy it requires”
Jessica Derschowitz·Entertainment Weekly
“despite Miranda's own personal connection to Larson's story, his direction seemed devoid of ego and purely focused on centering Larson”
Peter Debruge·Variety
“the film was stronger when the character was telling his story”
Jackson McHenry·Vulture
Biography, Comedy, Drama
On the brink of turning 30, a promising theater composer navigates love, friendship and the pressure to create something great before time runs out.
Lin-Manuel Miranda's directing debut earned wide praise for centering Jonathan Larson's story with humility and specificity, with Andrew Garfield's musical performance and Robin de Jesús's breakout turn drawing particular attention. The main fault line in criticism runs through the documentary-style framing device, which even admirers felt reduced Larson to his most famous work, and through the film's treatment of the AIDS crisis — expansive compared to its source material, but still viewed through the lens of a straight man who survived it, a perspective critics found incomplete.
“a totem for the thrills and trials of making art, with all the sacrifices and empathy it requires”
Jessica Derschowitz·Entertainment Weekly
“despite Miranda's own personal connection to Larson's story, his direction seemed devoid of ego and purely focused on centering Larson”
Peter Debruge·Variety
“the film was stronger when the character was telling his story”
Jackson McHenry·Vulture
Biography, Comedy, Drama